Giovanni's

Discover delicious pizza and classic Italian favorites at Giovanni's Pizza in Monticello, NY. Enjoy flavorful sandwiches like the Cuban, meatball sub, and Godfather, along with garlic knots, stromboli, and more. Friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere await you!

Welcome to Giovanni's

Signature Dining Experience

Giovanni's
Giovanni's
Giovanni's
Giovanni's

Giovanni's Pizza Restaurant welcomes you with open arms at 4457 NY-42, Monticello, NY. This inviting eatery stands as a local favorite, not just for its tasty pizza but also for its diverse menu that caters to every craving. Whether you're in the mood for a classic meatball sub or an exquisite eggplant parm, Giovanni's has it all. The bustling atmosphere buzzes with the chatter of satisfied diners and the savory aroma of freshly baked goods. Known especially for its pleasant staff, this is the kind of place that makes you feel at home. With peak times on Fridays reaching full capacity, it’s clear this spot is cherished within the community.

Location & Contact

Address

4457 NY-42, Monticello, NY 12701, United States

Phone

+1 845-794-8668

Social Media

About

Giovanni's
Giovanni's
Giovanni's
Giovanni's

Giovanni's is more than just a pizza place; it's a community hub where flavors and friendships meld. Located in Monticello, this restaurant thrives on the diverse culinary preferences of its patrons. Open daily, it prides itself on offering a menu packed with variety. The standout items, like the stromboli and mushroom slice, reflect both creativity and tradition. Regulars rave about their favorite garlic knots, providing the perfect start to any meal.

Frequent visitors rave about the rich flavors and generous portions, making every meal at Giovanni's memorable.

Local favorites, such as the eggplant parm, offer a comforting taste of home, while the sandwiches and wraps provide options for those on the go. Each plate is crafted with care, ensuring freshness and quality at every bite. Giovanni's also manages to keep the menu both vibrant and appealing, with a focus on today’s specials that keep locals coming back for more.

The commitment to quality shines through in every aspect, from the friendly service to the cozy atmosphere.

Touches like decor featuring classic pizza artwork and community events foster a warm, inviting vibe. Giovanni's values the community and often hosts special events that unite patrons over delicious food and good company. Mountain trails and scenic views surround Monticello, and Giovanni's serves as a perfect pit-stop for explorers hungry for hearty comfort food after a day out.

Work Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-6 PM
  • Monday11 AM-7 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-7 PM
  • Friday11 AM-7 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-7 PM

Giovanni's offers an exciting range of features to enhance your dining experience. The menu boasts an impressive selection of dishes, including traditional pizza, savory sandwiches, and unique wraps, totaling 22 delightful options. Standout items like the Cuban sandwich and the Godfather sandwich have garnered rave reviews from locals. An enticing specials board keeps things fresh, showcasing offerings like Beef Barkey Soup and Shrimp Platter. The restaurant caters to a busy crowd during lunch hours, making it a fantastic spot for a quick bite. While dinner is quieter, the atmosphere remains welcoming and service-oriented, ensuring every visit is a pleasure. Giovanni's amplifies community spirit through its dedicated staff and delicious meals.

Giovanni's

Giovanni's boasts a charming exterior that invites diners in from the bustling NY-42. The warm colors and inviting signage make it hard to resist. The outdoor seating area offers respite on sunny days and provides a casual atmosphere for enjoying meals al fresco. Locals often gather here, exchanging stories while savoring culinary delights. The vibe is lively yet relaxed, encapsulating the spirit of Monticello perfectly.

Customer Reviews

As Good as a Deli Gets, Fast,Courteous and Delicious!

J
Jeffrey P.

OMG. First time here, just passing through town. Got the meatball sub half - and it's huge! And the taste, it's exactly as I remember from my days growing up here. The texture of the hero was spot on!! Meatballs must have been cooking all day, delish!! If I'm still in town tomorrow, I'm coming back to try their eggplant parm!

S
Selene I.

Great subs here. I have been getting food here since I was a little kid and they were in their original location next to Paul Paskows liquor store where burger king is now. Their staff is friendly and good at their trade. Prices are fair. Never have had a bad experiance here in 30 years. You have to try their Godfather with everything!!!

C
C B.

Are you looking for delicious food? Good prices? It's here! If your looking for marble floors? Waiters to take your order & fine wine? Don't come here. I have been coming for 3 years now and the meatball sub is as delicious as the first time. The staff are friendly and helpful. Thanks for great food!

F
Francis V.

Giovanni's is a Monticello legend. Excellent menu. Great food. Home of the "Godfather" sub. There are probably poems written about that hero . Highly recommend.

P
Paul G.

Great food but the parking situation is horrible

B
Bill J.